Pie of the Tiger
  • Photos
  • Menu
  • Location
  • Work Hours
  • Business info
  • Reviews

Pie of the Tiger Menu

Menu Pie of the Tiger-1
Menu Pie of the Tiger-1
Menu Pie of the Tiger-2
Menu Pie of the Tiger-2
Menu Pie of the Tiger-3
Menu Pie of the Tiger-3
Menu Pie of the Tiger-4
Menu Pie of the Tiger-4
Menu Pie of the Tiger-5
Menu Pie of the Tiger-5

Bar Snacks

Bone-In Chicken Wings
$9.00
Boneless Chicken Wings
$9.00
Fried Mushrooms
$10.00
Jalapeno Poppers
$11.00
Mozzarella Sticks
$10.00
Pickle Fries
$11.00
Pizza House Cheese Bread
$6.00
Split Auddino's roll toasted with garlic butter, minced garlic, provolone & Italian seasoning. Comes with a side of red sauce.
Sample Basket
$16.00
Mozzarella sticks, fried mushrooms, jalapeno poppers & pickle fries with red sauce, ranch & Tiger sauce on the side.
Tater Wedges
$7.00
Garlic Parmesan Tiger Balls
$8.00
Fried dough balls tossed in garlic sauce, parmesan cheese & Italian seasoning with red sauce, ranch & Tiger sauce.

Between Bread

Italian Sub
$15.00
Jumbo pepperoni, genoa salami, ham, capicola and provolone on a toasted hoagie with tomato, red onions, romaine and banana peppers tossed in creamy Italian dressing.
Meatball Sub
$16.00
House meatballs. garlic butter, red sauce, provolone and shaved parmesan on a toasted hoagie roll.

Tiger Pizza

Build Your Own
$14.00
8" square pizza cut into 4 pieces. All pizzas come with provolone unless you specify otherwise. Choose your toppings and sauce.
Half & Half
$14.00
BBQ Chicken Pizza
$17.00
Provolone, chicken, red onions & bacon with BBQ sauce - no red sauce.
BCR
$16.00
Provolone, chicken & bacon with ranch on top - no red sauce.
Chicken Parmesan
$16.00
Garlic butter, minced garlic, provolone, roasted chicken, Italian seasoning, red sauce & shaved parmesan.
Dill Thrill
$15.00
Minced garlic, garlic butter, provolone & dill pickles with ranch & Old Bay hot sauce on top - no red sauce. Add bacon +1.50
Just Cheese Please
$15.00
Garlic Butter, minced garlic, provolone, feta, ricotta & Italian seasoning with red sauce.
Just Pepperoni
$15.00
Provolone & jumbo pepperoni with red sauce on top.
Margherita
$16.00
Garlic butter, minced garlic, provolone, tomatoes and ricotta with pesto on top - no red sauce.
Meatball Sundae
$17.00
Provolone, spicy house meatballs, shaved parmesan, red sauce, ricotta & Italian Seasoning.
The Big Cat
$18.00
Provolone, jumbo pepperoni, sausage, roasted mushrooms, green peppers, and black olives with red sauce on top
The Italian Job
$19.00
Genoa salami, capicola, jumbo pepperoni, ham, banana peppers and tomatoes with provolone, shaved parmesan and Italian dressing no red sauce.
Tiny Panther
$19.00
Provolone, cheddar, Italian sausage, ham & bacon with yellow mustard on top - no red sauce.

Dessert

Chocolate Strawberry Tiger Balls
$8.00
Fried dough balls rolled in powdered sugar & topped with chocolate sauce - side of strawberry coulis.

Pie of the Tiger offers a tantalizing menu that promises to satisfy a variety of tastes, perfect for those looking for a flavorful bite in a laid-back atmosphere. As a food reviewer, I must say, their offerings are both comforting and innovative, bringing familiar favorites with a twist.

Starting off with their Bar Snacks, you'll be treated to crispy, mouthwatering choices like Bone-In Chicken Wings and Boneless Chicken Wings. The wings come perfectly seasoned, offering a crunchy exterior with tender meat inside. If you're a fan of fried treats, the Fried Mushrooms provide a golden, crispy coating that pairs beautifully with a tangy dipping sauce. For those who love a bit of heat, the Jalapeno Poppers bring a spicy kick, while the gooey Mozzarella Sticks are a satisfying, cheesy indulgence.

Moving on to the heartier options, Between Bread presents two crowd-pleasers – the Italian Sub and the Meatball Sub. Both are packed with bold flavors, from savory meats to perfectly melted cheeses, all enveloped in fresh, soft bread.

The highlight, however, is the Tiger Pizza section. Whether you want to Build Your Own or opt for one of the signature combinations like BBQ Chicken PizzaBCR or the comforting Chicken Parmesan Pizza, there’s something to satisfy every craving. The Half & Half pizza also offers a great way to sample two different flavors in one.

And for dessert? The Chocolate Strawberry Tiger Balls are an absolute must-try, a sweet and decadent finish to any meal.

Pie of the Tiger's menu is a perfect mix of familiar comfort food and bold flavors, making it a great spot for anyone looking for a memorable meal.

Pie of the Tiger

Pie of the Tiger offers unique Sicilian-Detroit hybrid pizzas in Columbus, OH. Enjoy their 8" square pies with a variety of toppings. With affordable prices and great reviews, this pizza spot is a must-try for pizza lovers!

Follow Us
  • Yelp
Copyright 2025 All rights reserved.